The honest version
We sell crumb rubber, so take this with that in mind. But buyers who pick a material for the wrong reasons come back unhappy, and we want repeat customers. So here's where crumb rubber wins, where it doesn't, and where the answer is "depends on your spec."
In asphalt: GTR vs. polymer modifiers
Polymer-modified asphalt, commonly with SBS (styrene-butadiene-styrene), is the main alternative to rubber modification.
| Ground tire rubber (GTR) | Virgin polymer (e.g., SBS) | |
|---|---|---|
| Source | Recycled scrap tires | Petrochemical |
| Forms | Wet (asphalt rubber), terminal blend, dry process | Blended at terminal |
| Published use levels | FHWA: AR 10-22% of binder; terminal 5-15%; dry ~10% of binder | Per binder supplier |
| Hybrid option | GTR + polymer "hybrid" binders exist; FHWA publishes guidance on hybrid GTR binders |
FHWA's 2020 report describes how GTR modification is used across all three processes and how agencies grade the resulting binders. Some agencies grade GTR-modified binders under the same performance-grade system as polymer-modified ones (for example, Louisiana designates PG 76-22M with MSCR testing). The practical choice usually comes down to your agency's spec, your plant's equipment and cost.
Where crumb wins: recycled content, established specs in states like California and Arizona, dry-process options that need no special binder tank. Where it depends: plant equipment for wet process; agency approval for dry process.

In turf: crumb vs. alternative infills
NYSDOH lists the alternatives: EPDM and thermoplastic elastomer (TPE), recycled shoe material, and mineral- and plant-based options like sand, cork and coconut hulls. NYSDOH also notes that "any alternative infill materials would need to be subjected to the same rigorous physical and chemical testing that crumb rubber has undergone," and that "thermoplastic elastomer, for example, has been found to release greater amounts of PAHs in water and air than does crumb rubber."
| Infill | Notes |
|---|---|
| Crumb rubber (SBR, from tires) | Most studied; widely used; low cost; heat is a known consideration |
| EPDM / TPE | Virgin polymers; color options; higher cost |
| Sand | Ballast and stability; often mixed with rubber |
| Organic (cork, coconut, etc.) | Lower surface temps claimed by makers; needs moisture/maintenance |
The system manufacturer usually decides. We supply 10-20 and 8-16 crumb for systems that use it. See turf infill.
In molded goods: crumb vs. virgin rubber and EPDM
- Crumb rubber: low cost, recycled, black. The USTMA counts molded and extruded products as the largest ground rubber segment (485 thousand tons of scrap tires in 2021).
- EPDM granules: colored, UV-stable, more expensive. Often used as a fleck or top layer over a crumb core.
- Virgin compound: for parts that need tight physical properties; recycled crumb can be blended in as filler under ASTM D5603's framework.
Most mat and tile makers use crumb for the body and color granules for appearance. See molded products.
In playgrounds: bound rubber vs. loose fill
The CPSC Public Playground Safety Handbook covers both unitary surfaces (such as poured-in-place rubber and rubber tiles) and loose-fill materials (such as engineered wood fiber, wood chips, sand, pea gravel and shredded/recycled rubber). Every option has trade-offs in cost, accessibility and maintenance; the finished surface's impact performance is measured by ASTM F1292.
Crumb rubber's role here is the bound base course of unitary systems. See playground surfacing.
In fuel: TDF vs. coal
EPA states tires "produce the same amount of energy as oil and 25% more energy than coal." TDF's competition is the facility's primary fuel. Whether it pencils out depends on the facility's permits, feed system and fuel prices. See TDF.
Worked example: a quick cost lens
Mat face layer: EPDM vs. fine crumb
A mat maker currently uses a 100% EPDM face layer that's 20% of the product weight. Switching to a 50/50 EPDM and 30-minus face:
- Face layer per 10,000 lb of mats = 2,000 lb
- EPDM drops from 2,000 lb to 1,000 lb; 30-minus adds 1,000 lb
- Whether that saves money depends on your EPDM and crumb prices. Run your numbers, then test appearance and wear
We'll quote the crumb side so you can do the math.
Comparing materials? Get crumb priced in. Send grade, volume, delivery city/ZIP and your target price.
Request a QuoteFrequently asked questions
Is crumb rubber better than EPDM?
Different jobs. Crumb is lower cost and recycled; EPDM offers color and UV stability. Many products use both.
Is crumb rubber safe for turf fields?
NYSDOH's review concludes the potential for chemical exposure from crumb rubber in synthetic turf appears low, and EPA's 2019 federal report characterized tire crumb from 40 fields. Heat is a known consideration. Your owner and local health authorities govern.
Is rubberized asphalt better than polymer-modified?
They're both proven tools. Your agency spec and plant setup usually decide.
Sources: FHWA-HIF-20-043 (2020); FHWA Recycled Tire Rubber – Hybrid GTR Binders and Dry Added GTR (PDF); NYSDOH synthetic turf fact sheet; U.S. EPA 2019 tire crumb report; USTMA 2021 summary; CPSC Public Playground Safety Handbook; ASTM F1292; U.S. EPA TDF page.






